Explore The NRA Universe Of Websites

APPEARS IN News

Experiments on Liberty and a Local Laboratory

Monday, June 19, 2023

Experiments on Liberty and a Local Laboratory

Ninety years ago, U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis described a novel business regulation in a case then before the Court as one that “involves a vast extension of the area of control” exercised by the state. In an often-cited reference, he urged the Court to uphold the scheme. “Denial of the right to experiment may be fraught with serious consequences to the nation. It is one of the happy incidents of the federal system that a single courageous state may, if its citizens choose, serve as a laboratory; and try novel social and economic experiments without risk to the rest of the country.”

The other members of the Court were unmoved by his enthusiasm, finding that the interest in exploring the “uncharted seas” of economic and social sciences could not transcend the limitations imposed by the Constitution. “The principle is imbedded in our constitutional system that there are certain essentials of liberty with which the State is not entitled to dispense in the interest of experiments.”  

Although the issue before the Court didn’t involve firearms, arguably one such legislative experiment now is gun control, and the laboratory in this instance is the District of Columbia. A few weeks ago, a spokesperson for the national gun control group Giffords was clear that the formula couldn’t be more obvious. “There is no debate. Lawmakers can save lives, reduce violence, and make their states safer by following a simple blueprint: pass gun violence prevention laws.”

The same group praises Washington, D.C. for having “enacted some of the strongest gun violence prevention legislation in the nation.” Indeed, the checklist of gun laws adopted in the Nation’s capital stops just short of a complete ban on firearms, with gun owner registration, “universal” background checks, “assault weapon” and “large capacity” magazine bans, a prohibitive concealed carry law, a gun offender registry, and lots more of questionable validity given the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in NYSRPA v. Bruen. The benefits of living in this exemplar of near-ideal gun control would, one expect, be boosted by proximity to adjacent Maryland (Giffords A-rated) and B-rated Virginia.

If only life were that simple.  

The D.C. Police Union, representing the sworn officers of the Metropolitan Police Department (MPD), reports that as of June 6, the number of homicides in the District surpassed 100, being the earliest point in the year that the City had reached the triple-digit marker in two decades. The union’s statement provides additional context: over the last ten years, “the average date that we have reached this grim marker is October 25.” Homicides in some parts of D.C. are up by 133% this year compared to 2022, and are not the only violent crime on the upswing. Robberies citywide have increased by 34%, and carjackings have increased by 57%.       

A Washington Post headline concurs: “D.C.-area carjackings have soared.” Carjacking has “grown at a staggering rate in the D.C. area during the height of the coronavirus pandemic and that continues to surge,” increasing from approximately 200 crimes in 2018 across D.C. and its neighboring jurisdictions to more than a 1,000 by the end of 2022. Not only is there a steady increase year over year, but juvenile perpetrators are overtaking adults in committing this crime.

The Washington Post article includes an awkwardly titled “carjacking tips from police.” The law enforcement hints on how to avoid being carjacked include trusting your instincts, parking in areas with good lighting and visibility, and keeping car doors locked, even when driving. “And, if you are threatened for your car, police recommend giving it up to avoid any personal injury.” Notably absent is advice on lawfully carrying a firearm for personal protection against would-be criminals.  

The crooks themselves are uninhibited by the District’s strict gun laws – and with good reason. Data in a 2023 D.C. Sentencing Commission report reveals that out of a total of 5,558 MPD arrests for carrying a pistol without a license (CPWL) made between 2018 and 2022, 56.6% (3,146 cases) were “no papered” (“the prosecuting authority … elected not to immediately file charges in Superior Court related to the arrest”) or were closed without a conviction. Only 97 cases (1.74%) ultimately resulted in a prison sentence. The figures on arrests and dispositions for “unlawful possession of a firearm” (UPF) offenses show the odds in favor of lawbreakers were pretty good, too. Out of 2,149 total arrests made for UPF crimes in the same time period, the majority (62.6%, or 1,346 cases) were “no papered” or closed without a conviction. Of the remaining cases that resulted in a conviction and sentencing for UPF, only 14.5% (312 cases) concluded with the offender behind bars.

Our earlier alert on the impact of gun control in Vermont (“Is gun control making Vermont less safe?”) cautioned that it’s an oversimplification to conclude that fluctuations in the violent crime rates rest on the relative strength of a jurisdiction’s gun control laws. The case with the District of Columbia is no different. Common sense suggests, though, that D.C.’s gun laws are doing little to impede crime, being more honored in the breach than in the observance.

Undoubtedly, gun control advocates will find a way to explain why following their “simple blueprint” in D.C. hasn’t led to reduced crime or increased public safety – Giffords, for one, makes a point of stating (about a jurisdiction with no gun stores and just two licensed FFLs) that “firearms purchased in DC are rarely used in crimes.”

Going back to that 1932 Supreme Court case, the Court laid down a different and preferable scientific method for legislators to follow. “[U]nreasonable or arbitrary interference or restrictions cannot be saved…merely by calling them experimental.  It is not necessary to challenge the authority of the states to indulge in experimental legislation; but it would be strange and unwarranted doctrine to hold that they may do so by enactments which transcend the limitations imposed upon them by the Federal Constitution.”

TRENDING NOW
Third Circuit Strikes Some New Jersey Carry Restrictions in NRA Case

Thursday, September 11, 2025

Third Circuit Strikes Some New Jersey Carry Restrictions in NRA Case

Yesterday, the Third Circuit Court of Appeals issued an opinion in Siegel v. Platkin, striking some of the carry restrictions New Jersey enacted in response to the NRA’s landmark Supreme Court victory, New York State Rifle & ...

Due Process: The Backbone of Legal Legitimacy

News  

Monday, September 8, 2025

Due Process: The Backbone of Legal Legitimacy

Close observers of the gun debate often see references to due process.

Gun Control “Journalist” Says the Quiet Part Out Loud

News  

Monday, September 8, 2025

Gun Control “Journalist” Says the Quiet Part Out Loud

Pure gun control. As in disarmament and banning of firearms. It’s rare that anti-gunners get straight to the exact point that we have been warning of for decades. 

The Desperate Deflection to the “Red State Murder Problem”

News  

Monday, September 8, 2025

The Desperate Deflection to the “Red State Murder Problem”

California Governor Gavin Newsom (D) may have thought he had scored against President Donald Trump in a recent war of words over rampant crime and the deployment of federal law enforcement agents to Democratic-led cities

NRA Files Amicus Brief Urging SCOTUS to Hear Challenge to Washington’s Magazine Ban

Monday, September 8, 2025

NRA Files Amicus Brief Urging SCOTUS to Hear Challenge to Washington’s Magazine Ban

Today, the National Rifle Association filed an amicus brief urging the U.S. Supreme Court to grant certiorari in a case challenging Washington State’s ban on firearm magazines that hold more than 10 rounds.

Illinois: Governor Signs Mandatory Firearm Storage Law

Wednesday, September 3, 2025

Illinois: Governor Signs Mandatory Firearm Storage Law

Earlier this month, Governor JB Pritzker signed Senate Bill 8 into law. This legislation imposes new mandatory firearm storage requirements on law-abiding gun owners.  

Update: North Carolina House Reschedules Veto Override Vote

Tuesday, August 26, 2025

Update: North Carolina House Reschedules Veto Override Vote

Today, the House rescheduled the veto override vote on Senate Bill 50, Freedom to Carry NC, to Monday, September 22. 

Minnesota: Senate Gun Violence Prevention Working Group Meeting on Monday

Friday, September 12, 2025

Minnesota: Senate Gun Violence Prevention Working Group Meeting on Monday

On Monday, September 15th, the Minnesota Senate will hold a special working group on "gun violence prevention."

Washington Post Admits that Anti-gun Lawfare “Cannot be the Solution” to Crime

News  

Monday, March 17, 2025

Washington Post Admits that Anti-gun Lawfare “Cannot be the Solution” to Crime

In a turnabout worthy of Invasion of the Body Snatchers, The Washington Post (WAPO) published an editorial last Tuesday criticizing the gun control movement for ignoring the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act (PLCAA) and pursuing its agenda in ...

Supreme Court Review Sought in NRA-Backed Challenge to California’s Magazine Ban

Friday, August 15, 2025

Supreme Court Review Sought in NRA-Backed Challenge to California’s Magazine Ban

Today, a Petition for Certiorari was filed asking the U.S. Supreme Court to hear Duncan v. Bonta, a case—backed by the National Rifle Association and California Rifle & Pistol Association—challenging California’s prohibition on magazines capable of holding ...

MORE TRENDING +
LESS TRENDING -

More Like This From Around The NRA

NRA ILA

Established in 1975, the Institute for Legislative Action (ILA) is the "lobbying" arm of the National Rifle Association of America. ILA is responsible for preserving the right of all law-abiding individuals in the legislative, political, and legal arenas, to purchase, possess and use firearms for legitimate purposes as guaranteed by the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.