Explore The NRA Universe Of Websites

APPEARS IN News

Smith & Wesson’s Clinton-Era Agreement Resurrected in Canadian Lawsuit

Monday, August 4, 2025

Smith & Wesson’s Clinton-Era Agreement Resurrected in Canadian Lawsuit

In 2000, as part of a settlement of dozens of product liability/negligence lawsuits brought by local governments and the threat of litigation by the federal government, the then-British-owned gunmaker Smith & Wesson signed a deal brokered by the Clinton White House. In exchange for a full settlement of all claims that were raised or could have been raised, the company agreed to develop “authorized user technology” (a.k.a. “smart guns”) and incorporate that technology in all new firearm models within 36 months. The NRA described the deal as requiring manufacturers to meet unproven “bureaucratic mandates of capricious changes to gun design.” Smith & Wesson faced an immediate backlash from retailers and the gun-owning public and its sales plummeted; a year later, the company was sold. The new Bush administration declined to enforce the agreement and, in the end, the only thing of substance the litigation accomplished was, ironically, the enactment of the federal Protection of Commerce in Lawful Arms Act (PLCAA).  

Now, however, a new decision by the Ontario Court of Appeal in Canada has sought to squeeze some further anti-gun utility out of the agreement. The case, Price v. Smith & Wesson Corp.,  2025 ONCA 452, is a proposed class action lawsuit alleging that the gunmaker is liable for injuries and deaths caused by the criminal misuse of a stolen gun.

In July 2018, Faisal Hussain randomly shot at pedestrians before opening fire into businesses in the area of Toronto’s Danforth Avenue. He used a Smith & Wesson M&P 40 handgun to kill two people and wound thirteen others before he killed himself.

Hussain had never applied for nor been granted a firearms license (in Canada, handguns are restricted firearms and require a restricted possession and acquisition license). The handgun he used had been lawfully imported into Canada and stolen in a break-and-enter at a Saskatchewan gun dealer’s three years earlier. It is unclear how Hussain obtained the handgun, but a CBC article speculated that Hussain’s older brother, who had a criminal history and ties to both a street gang and a home in Toronto “where police seized 33 firearms” and over 40 kg. of an illegal drug, “may have once possessed the handgun his brother used in the Danforth shooting.” A 2019 Toronto Police report outlines Hussain’s extensive interactions with school officials, medical/mental health professionals, and the police in the years leading up to the shooting, raising concerns over his risk of harm to self and others.

The lawsuit in which the victims and their families are seeking millions of dollars in damages is solely against Smith & Wesson and based in claims of negligence, strict liability and public nuisance.

According to the plaintiffs, the lynchpin of the suit is the 2000 agreement:

the essence of the cause of action is that Smith & Wesson was aware of the risks posed by lost and stolen handguns yet sold products in Canada without any safety devices, mechanical or electronic, to prevent unauthorized use. Safety devices were not included even though the company’s products were frequently lost and stolen in Canada, recovered at Canadian crime scenes, and the subject of crime gun traces by Ontario law enforcement agencies.

Specifically, the plaintiffs pointed to the fact that as early as 1998, Smith & Wesson began developing “smart gun” or “authorized user technology” and filed at least seven related patent applications. It later entered into the agreement that required it to incorporate “authorized user technology” in its new firearm designs. Even though Smith & Wesson did not develop any prototypes from its patents; eventually permitted them to lapse; and never actually adopted authorized user technology, the plaintiffs nonetheless allege that this is enough to establish a claim in negligence because the defendant recognized the risk of unauthorized use and had developed technology to make its products less susceptible to that risk.

Ontario law requires a judge to certify a class action before it may proceed, and in this case, the judge initially dealing with the certification motion bifurcated the claims. The strict liability and public nuisance claims were struck, as it was plain and obvious that they were doomed to fail, but the negligence claim was allowed to proceed to the second phase of the hearing. The question here was not whether the plaintiffs’ claims were likely to succeed on the merits, but whether the claims could appropriately be prosecuted as a class proceeding. This required “some basis in fact” to show that there was a common issue as an essential ingredient of each proposed class member’s claim, which justified the court in avoiding an individual trial of each. The common element alleged was design negligence, the failure to incorporate authorized user technology. 

The motions judge denied certification because this evidentiary threshold required some expert testimony that an M&P 40 without authorized user technology was a design defect and that safer, economically feasible ways to manufacture the product were available, which was “a vastly more difficult matter to prove than proving that Smith & Wesson had already developed patents for a prototype of a gun with authorized user technology.” For instance, there was no evidence that the technology could be incorporated without impairing the utility of the M&P 40 for police forces and the military, the end users for which the gun was designed. It did “not follow that because something can be designed, even something beneficial, that it is careless or below the standard of care not to implement the design… Put shortly, the design standards set by this agreement are good public policy independent of design negligence but they do not provide some basis in fact for design negligence.”

On appeal, however, the Ontario Court of Appeal reversed and certified the plaintiffs’ claim in negligence, in a decision that highlighted the 2000 agreement. The motions judge, the decision held, erred in requiring expert evidence; all that was needed at this stage was “some minimal evidence.” The 2000 agreement provided this “minimal evidence” and therefore, “some basis in fact.” In signing the agreement,

the defendant acknowledged that the use of authorized user technology might prevent unauthorized users from wielding handguns. So there is some basis in fact to support that contention that had the gun been outfitted with authorized user technology, Hussain might have been prevented from using the gun and causing the harm that he did. And if that is so, then the failure to include the technology on the gun was a but-for cause of the injuries and deaths that ensued.

The decision also ruled the 2000 agreement, the patents, and an “expert regulator’s report on the dangers associated with unauthorized use” all pointed to a conclusion that a reasonable company in the defendant’s position would have been aware of the connection between unauthorized firearm use and harm to third parties. The agreement also featured in the appeals court’s decision to allow a claim for punitive damages to proceed: “The commitment to implementing authorized user technology, its apparent feasibility, and the retreat in the face of legislative immunity provide ‘some minimal evidence’ that the defendant’s conduct amounted to ‘malicious, oppressive and high-handed misconduct’…”

While all of this is preliminary procedural wrangling that doesn’t yet reach the merits of the actual liability issues, the decision makes it possible for the claims to eventually succeed. In the meantime, Smith & Wesson may opt to seek leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.

These kinds of lawsuits not only illustrate the failure of gun control but exemplify why the PLCAA was enacted. In June, the United States Supreme Court unanimously upheld the PLCAA’s “core purpose” of barring litigation to hold law-abiding gun manufacturers liable where the suit is founded on a third party’s criminal use of the company’s product. There, as here, one of the claims was the defendants failed to develop so-called “smart gun” technology, with the plaintiffs insisting that the legal and economic responsibility for the harm perpetrated by criminals, with illegally obtained firearms, ultimately lies with the highly-regulated manufacturer of an equally highly-regulated and lawful product.

Should liability be ultimately imposed against the defendant in Canada, we predict the outcome for public safety will be negligible, at best, and likely adverse. Authorized user technology is far from dependable (here, here and here, including a case where a “smart” gun’s security features were easily defeated), and, unfortunately, criminals will continue to be criminals. 

TRENDING NOW
Arizona: Anti-Gun Lawmakers Waste No Time Taking Aim at Second Amendment Rights

Friday, November 6, 2026

Arizona: Anti-Gun Lawmakers Waste No Time Taking Aim at Second Amendment Rights

Just hours after Election Day, anti-gun lawmakers in Arizona are already signaling plans to pursue gun control in 2027, leaving law-abiding Arizonans to face the harsh reality that a consequential legislative session lies ahead.  

The Election is Over: Now the Real Work Begins

News  

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

The Election is Over: Now the Real Work Begins

While the complete picture from the 2026 midterm elections is still emerging, the results, to say the least, were not what gun owners wanted. Anti-gun forces took control of the U.S. Senate and House of ...

Article by NRA-ILA Litigation Director Joseph Greenlee and Professor George Mocsary Published in Yale Law Journal Forum

News  

Monday, November 2, 2026

Article by NRA-ILA Litigation Director Joseph Greenlee and Professor George Mocsary Published in Yale Law Journal Forum

A new Essay authored by NRA-ILA Litigation Director Joseph Greenlee and University of Wyoming College of Law Professor George Mocsary has been published in the Yale Law Journal Forum.

Jive Turkeys: Everytown Gears Up to Spoil Thanksgiving with Gobbledygook

News  

Monday, November 17, 2025

Jive Turkeys: Everytown Gears Up to Spoil Thanksgiving with Gobbledygook

Thanksgiving in America isn’t just about food, family and football. According to a survey published by casino.ca (with its Great Thanksgiving Family Feud Map), the holiday typically “comes with a slice of family chaos and a touch of ...

Trump’s Gun Rights Policies Making America Safe Again

News  

Monday, November 2, 2026

Trump’s Gun Rights Policies Making America Safe Again

“Crime’s way down thanks to Trump — Dems will fight to send it back up,” warns an editorial in the N.Y. Post. “Law-and-order works. Immigration enforcement works. And — like it or not — Trump’s ...

New York:  Gov. Kathy Hochul Signs Gun Ban in State Budget Process

Wednesday, May 27, 2026

New York: Gov. Kathy Hochul Signs Gun Ban in State Budget Process

On Wednesday, May 27, Gov. Kathy Hochul signed S.9005C, which “enacts into law major components” of the state’s public protection and general government budget.

The Hunting Vote: What’s at Stake in 2026 and Beyond

News  

Monday, November 2, 2026

The Hunting Vote: What’s at Stake in 2026 and Beyond

As votes are now being cast nationwide, one influential voting bloc is drawing renewed attention: America's hunters, sportsmen, and sportswomen.

U.S. House Passes Repeal of Social Security Administration Gun Grab, Begins Rolling Back Obama Era Executive Gun Control

News  

Friday, February 3, 2017

U.S. House Passes Repeal of Social Security Administration Gun Grab, Begins Rolling Back Obama Era Executive Gun Control

On Thursday, the U.S. House of Representatives issued a strong statement in support of the Second Amendment by passing H.J. Res. 40, which would repeal Barack Obama’s scandalous attempt to grab guns from thousands of vulnerable, ...

District Court Declines to Enter Agreement to Invalidate Florida’s Waiting Period Law in NRA Case and Invites Amici Participation

Thursday, October 29, 2026

District Court Declines to Enter Agreement to Invalidate Florida’s Waiting Period Law in NRA Case and Invites Amici Participation

Yesterday, U.S. District Judge Steven D. Merryday denied the parties’ joint motion for entry of judgment in the National Rifle Association’s challenge to Florida’s firearm waiting period law. The case, Dunn v. Glass, remains pending ...

Different Election, Same Billionaire, Same Gun Control Agenda

News  

Monday, October 26, 2026

Different Election, Same Billionaire, Same Gun Control Agenda

Another election, same former New York City mayor Michael Bloomberg working to shape the nation’s gun laws. For years, NRA has exposed Bloomberg’s relentless efforts to export New York style gun restrictions to the rest ...

MORE TRENDING +
LESS TRENDING -

More Like This From Around The NRA

NRA ILA

Established in 1975, the Institute for Legislative Action (ILA) is the "lobbying" arm of the National Rifle Association of America. ILA is responsible for preserving the right of all law-abiding individuals in the legislative, political, and legal arenas, to purchase, possess and use firearms for legitimate purposes as guaranteed by the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.