Explore The NRA Universe Of Websites

APPEARS IN News

Ivy League Law Professors Argue for an End to U.S. Constitutional Republic

Tuesday, September 6, 2022

Ivy League Law Professors Argue for an End to U.S. Constitutional Republic

Have you ever wondered what it is like to be educated in America’s most prestigious legal academies? If so, you’re in luck, as the New York Times published an op-ed last week co-authored by two professors from arguably the two most elite law schools in the nation. The brilliant insight they wish to share with the world beyond their ivied towers says all that needs to said about how America’s top lawyers are being “educated” these days. The article’s thesis is that America’s constitutional republic should be disbanded.

The article, “The Constitution is Broken and Should Not Be Reclaimed” was written by Ryan D. Doerfler and Samuel Moyn of the law schools at Harvard and Yale, respectively. They advocate for “pretty openly defying the Constitution to get to a more democratic order,” one that would be “insulate[d] … from judicial review.”

The American Constitution and other founding era documents provide the framework upon which our entire system of government is built. Like much of the law though, the constitution provides some very clear requirements, and some others that have required interpretation by American courts.

Thus, there remains a large area of debate about constitutional meaning that varies from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, with legislatures and inferior courts at the federal and state levels resolving most disputes and establishing the rules that apply within their spheres of authority.

This system has generally provided a peaceful, prosperous, innovative, and relatively (although not perfectly) fair environment for Americans to thrive. The results speak for themselves, as the comparatively young country of the United States is the predominant economic, military, technological, and cultural power in the world today.

Of course, fundamental constitutional debates remain, including how to interpret the Constitution’s meaning and apply it to current conditions and whether the deliberately limited and measured pace of federal government operations can keep up with the rapidly changing world.

Doerfler and Moyn, however, believe the entire system must be scrapped in favor of one that prioritizes pure majoritarian politics. They embrace this idea because they are far to the left politically; their side has recently suffered some setbacks at the Supreme Court; they admit the Constitution doesn’t necessarily embody their policy preferences; and they manifestly believe demographic trends and political dynamics favor their views.

As pure theory, contemplating different governmental arrangements may be an interesting thought experiment. Yet American lawyers – as officers of the courts and guardians of the country’s legal order – swear an oath to defend and uphold the Constitution. It’s difficult to imagine how publicly advocating how to subvert the Constitution is consistent with this oath.

It is also ironic, given the Biden Administration’s obsessive focus on combatting supposed rightwing extremism, a term that always seems to alight on ordinary Americans of limited means and influence. What, after all, could be more extreme than arguing for Congress to openly defy the Constitution and end America as we know it? The authors, moreover, are not just two random cranks on social media. They are law professors with the opportunity to instill their views in students who will go on to occupy some of the most influential legal jobs in the public and private sector.

Messy as it is, America’s constitutional system currently gives all sides the ability to participate, and when they do not prevail, the hope to regroup and work within the system to fight another day.

But, as ever, elites like Doerfler and Moyn want to rig the system so that they always win.

That didn’t work out so well for King George III, however. And as long as the American spirit prevails in organizations like the NRA that treasure and promote our founding ideals and aspirations, anti-constitutionalist like these two professors will be consigned to seethe in the pages of likeminded publications.

It is instructive, however, to know what some ambitious “reformers” would do if they could.

Thanks to the Second Amendment and the rest of the Constitution, however, they cannot. May it ever be so.

IN THIS ARTICLE
United States Constitution
TRENDING NOW
U.S. House Passes Reconciliation Bill, Removing Suppressors from the National Firearms Act

News  

Second Amendment  

Thursday, May 22, 2025

U.S. House Passes Reconciliation Bill, Removing Suppressors from the National Firearms Act

Earlier today, the U.S. House of Representatives passed H.R.1 the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, which included Section 2 of the Hearing Protection Act, completely removing suppressors from the National Firearms Act (NFA).

U.S. Representative Suggests TRIPLING ($600) Suppressor Tax!

News  

Tuesday, May 27, 2025

U.S. Representative Suggests TRIPLING ($600) Suppressor Tax!

Excellent news for gun owners came last week when the U.S. House of Representatives passed President Donald Trump's One Big Beautiful Bill, which includes the complete removal of suppressors from the National Firearms Act (NFA). 

Loot Canal: U.S. Taxpayers Funded Bizarre Dental “Gun Violence” Research

News  

Monday, June 2, 2025

Loot Canal: U.S. Taxpayers Funded Bizarre Dental “Gun Violence” Research

When the Biden-Harris administration made clear they intended to use a “whole-of-government” approach to suppress Second Amendment rights, few could have predicted their efforts would extend all the way to the dentist’s office.

Australia’s Gun Laws, Failing in Different Ways

News  

Monday, June 2, 2025

Australia’s Gun Laws, Failing in Different Ways

Everything is relative, so the saying goes, which means that once in a while, it’s instructive to read about the gun laws and the state of gun rights in other countries. 

Twenty-four State Attorneys General Urge Congress to Pass H.R. 38

News  

Monday, June 2, 2025

Twenty-four State Attorneys General Urge Congress to Pass H.R. 38

On May 21, two dozen state attorneys general sent a letter to the leadership of the U.S. House of Representatives, urging that body to pass H.R. 38, the Constitutional Concealed Carry Reciprocity Act.

ATF Updates “Brady Permit Chart,” Reduces Need for Redundant NICS Checks

News  

Monday, June 2, 2025

ATF Updates “Brady Permit Chart,” Reduces Need for Redundant NICS Checks

We have been reporting on recent reforms by ATF to make its operations more transparent, professional, and public safety focused and less openly hostile to law abiding gun owners and the industries that serve them. 

Anti-gun Shakedown Machine Now Targets Toy Gun Sellers

News  

Monday, June 2, 2025

Anti-gun Shakedown Machine Now Targets Toy Gun Sellers

The pro-Second Amendment community understands that guns are not toys.

Texas Bill Would Put Local “Buybacks” Out of Business, Ending an Anti-gun Charade

News  

Monday, June 2, 2025

Texas Bill Would Put Local “Buybacks” Out of Business, Ending an Anti-gun Charade

As Texas House Bill 3053 heads to Governor Abbott’s desk, it is serving as a broader reminder to all states of the gun “buybacks” scam, only this time with a legislative solution to this anti-gun mainstay.

ATF Invites FFLs Zeroed Out Under Biden-Harris to Reapply

News  

Tuesday, May 27, 2025

ATF Invites FFLs Zeroed Out Under Biden-Harris to Reapply

Among all the infringements of the Second Amendment perpetrated by the Biden-Harris regime, one of the most punitive and consequential was ATF’s “zero tolerance” enforcement policy for Federal Firearms Licensees (FFLs). 

Florida: Governor DeSantis Signs Legislation to Remove 2A Restrictions During Emergencies

Thursday, May 29, 2025

Florida: Governor DeSantis Signs Legislation to Remove 2A Restrictions During Emergencies

Yesterday, May 28, Governor Ron DeSantis signed House Bill 6025 into law protecting our Second Amendment Rights during a state of emergency. The new law became effective upon the governor's signature.  

MORE TRENDING +
LESS TRENDING -

More Like This From Around The NRA

NRA ILA

Established in 1975, the Institute for Legislative Action (ILA) is the "lobbying" arm of the National Rifle Association of America. ILA is responsible for preserving the right of all law-abiding individuals in the legislative, political, and legal arenas, to purchase, possess and use firearms for legitimate purposes as guaranteed by the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.