Explore The NRA Universe Of Websites

APPEARS IN News

Government Continues to Downplay, Distort Data on Defensive Gun Use

Monday, September 11, 2023

Government Continues to Downplay, Distort Data on Defensive Gun Use

In 2021, John R. Lott, Jr., the president of the Crime Prevention Research Center (CPRC) released a paper on the “serious errors” he found in Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) reports purporting to track “active shooter incidents” (ASIs). The FBI’s annual or biannual reports – which aim “to provide federal, state and local law enforcement with data so they can better understand how to prevent, prepare for, respond to, and recover from these incidents” – contained, according to Dr. Lott, critical errors. In one instance, the failure to include “many major missed cases” meant that once those cases were accounted for, what the FBI had presented as a drastic increase in ASIs between 2000 and 2013 was actually a “slight, statistically insignificant upward trend over the 38 years from 1977 through 2014,” and one that was, moreover, attributable to high numbers in a single year (2012).

Another error highlighted in the 2021 paper was the FBI’s repeated exclusion of cases where armed citizens intervened in attacks, with the corrected data establishing a significantly more favorable depiction of defensive gun uses. This included Dr. Lott identifying at least six missing cases in 2018-19 in which a concealed handgun permit-holder stopped the attacker. The FBI had reported that, between 2014 and 2019, citizens with permitted concealed handguns stopped an attack in nine out of 145 cases (6.2%); as corrected, the figure more than doubled to over 15 percent. (Further research was required to identify additional concealed carry cases missed by the FBI prior to 2014.)  

Interestingly, the Washington Post’s fact-checker, Glenn Kessler, contacted the FBI for comments regarding the issues Lott raised. “The FBI brushed aside repeated efforts by The Fact Checker to discuss its reports and the questions raised by Lott. ‘We have no additional information to provide other than what is provided within the active shooter reports on our website,’ the agency said in an emailed statement.”

A new article by Dr. Lott maintains that the FBI persists in its unfortunate practice of massively underreporting incidents in which armed civilians have thwarted active shootings. “While the FBI claims that just 4.6 percent of active shootings were stopped by law-abiding citizens carrying guns, the percentage that [the CPRC] found was 35.7 percent. I am more confident that we have identified a higher share of recent cases, and our figure for 2022 was even higher – 41.3 percent.”

The corrected statistics are even more compelling once adjusted for just the locations where armed individuals are permitted to carry. Although the FBI dataset does not break down cases between those occurring in “gun-free” zones and others, the CPRC found that in “places where law-abiding citizens are allowed to carry firearms, the percentage of active shootings that were stopped is 51 percent. For 2022, that figure is a remarkable 63.5 percent” – a stunningly persuasive endorsement on the benefits of lawful carry.  (The specific data used by the CPRC is available at its website, here.)

Another study lends support to the CPRC’s findings, being the results of a national survey analyzing firearm ownership and use released last year by William English (McDonough School of Business, Georgetown University). Admittedly, this doesn’t use the FBI’s metric of “active shooter incident” (which applies only to public places and excludes shootings from gang or drug violence), but nonetheless offers valuable insight into how often firearms are used in defense of self and others. 

The study found that more than 81.4 million Americans aged 18 and over own firearms, with approximately 31.1% (25.3 million) reporting having used a gun to defend themselves or their property, often on more than one occasion. Extrapolating the figures, these “gun owners have been involved in … approximately 50 million defensive incidents. Assuming that defensive uses of firearms are distributed roughly equally across years, this suggests at least 1.67 million defensive uses of firearms per year in which firearms owners have defended themselves or their property through the discharge, display, or mention of a firearm (excluding military service, police work, or work as a security guard).” Footnote 9 clarifies that “this estimate is inherently conservative;” if, for instance, those who do not personally own firearms are included in the estimate, it “could be substantially higher – perhaps as high as 2.8 million per year.”

Lott’s article concedes that data collection and classification mistakes may happen, although this doesn’t explain why the problems with the FBI’s reporting continue even after updated, corrected information is made available. The FBI’s “data on active shootings is missing so many defensive gun uses that it’s hard to believe it isn’t intentional.”

It is, of course, irresponsible to manipulate data to further a preferred political narrative, and it is much more egregiously so if the entity involved is a publicly funded and supposedly nonpartisan government agency whose information is relied on by media, courts, law enforcement, and legislators. President Joe Biden – who has himself been so frequently and consistently caught out making false claims about guns that even CNN has called him on it – is already campaigning on a sweeping new gun control platform. The success of his anti-Second Amendment agenda rests on undermining facts and evidence, and convincing Americans that defensive gun use is a fantasy.

TRENDING NOW
Gun Control “Journalist” Says the Quiet Part Out Loud

News  

Monday, September 8, 2025

Gun Control “Journalist” Says the Quiet Part Out Loud

Pure gun control. As in disarmament and banning of firearms. It’s rare that anti-gunners get straight to the exact point that we have been warning of for decades. 

The Desperate Deflection to the “Red State Murder Problem”

News  

Monday, September 8, 2025

The Desperate Deflection to the “Red State Murder Problem”

California Governor Gavin Newsom (D) may have thought he had scored against President Donald Trump in a recent war of words over rampant crime and the deployment of federal law enforcement agents to Democratic-led cities

Illinois: Governor Signs Mandatory Firearm Storage Law

Wednesday, September 3, 2025

Illinois: Governor Signs Mandatory Firearm Storage Law

Earlier this month, Governor JB Pritzker signed Senate Bill 8 into law. This legislation imposes new mandatory firearm storage requirements on law-abiding gun owners.  

Due Process: The Backbone of Legal Legitimacy

News  

Monday, September 8, 2025

Due Process: The Backbone of Legal Legitimacy

Close observers of the gun debate often see references to due process.

Florida: Second Amendment Sales Tax Holiday Signed by Governor

Monday, July 7, 2025

Florida: Second Amendment Sales Tax Holiday Signed by Governor

Governor Ron DeSantis recently signed the Florida Budget for Fiscal Year 2025–2026, which includes a Second Amendment sales tax holiday from September 8 through December 31, 2025. The NRA is thankful for Governor DeSantis’ strong ...

Report: Senior ATF Official Joins (Private) Firearm Prohibition Lobby

News  

Tuesday, September 2, 2025

Report: Senior ATF Official Joins (Private) Firearm Prohibition Lobby

The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) is the federal agency whose jurisdiction encompasses federal firearms laws. 

Arkansas Atrocity Highlights Need for Reform in Rules Governing Carry in Public Parks

News  

Monday, August 25, 2025

Arkansas Atrocity Highlights Need for Reform in Rules Governing Carry in Public Parks

On the heels of the shocking and seemingly random murder of a couple in an Arkansas state park while they were walking a trail with their young children, many are revisiting their self-defense plans in the great ...

Update: North Carolina House Reschedules Veto Override Vote

Tuesday, August 26, 2025

Update: North Carolina House Reschedules Veto Override Vote

Today, the House rescheduled the veto override vote on Senate Bill 50, Freedom to Carry NC, to Monday, September 22. 

Grassroots Spotlight: Oklahoma Rifle Association Annual State Convention

Take Action  

Monday, September 8, 2025

Grassroots Spotlight: Oklahoma Rifle Association Annual State Convention

Each year, the Oklahoma Rifle Association (ORA), the NRA's State Association for Oklahoma, hosts its Annual State Convention in August. 

ABAs Latest Resolution Continues to Ignore Liberty and Hinder Justice for Gun Owners

News  

Tuesday, September 2, 2025

ABAs Latest Resolution Continues to Ignore Liberty and Hinder Justice for Gun Owners

Last month, the American Bar Association (ABA), via its Standing Committee on Gun Violence, passed yet another anti-gun resolution at their annual meeting in Toronto (the venue should serve as a clue regarding their commitment ...

MORE TRENDING +
LESS TRENDING -

More Like This From Around The NRA

NRA ILA

Established in 1975, the Institute for Legislative Action (ILA) is the "lobbying" arm of the National Rifle Association of America. ILA is responsible for preserving the right of all law-abiding individuals in the legislative, political, and legal arenas, to purchase, possess and use firearms for legitimate purposes as guaranteed by the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.