Another week, another set of stories chronicling the sad demise of individual rights in the United Kingdom, where gardeners with pruning tools are treated like dangerous criminals and insulting crooks who plunder your store attracts more police attention than the thieves themselves. This is what an English-speaking culture without a right to arms or self-defense looks like, a cringeworthy nanny culture that treats normal adults like children and shrinks from the challenge of confronting real lawlessness.
In late July, U.K. news outlet the Guardian published an article titled, “Man carrying home his gardening tools arrested by armed police in Manchester.” The item recounted the story of 35-year-old theatre technical manager Samuel Rowe, who was arrested while trimming hedges with a gardening tool outside his home in Manchester. Rowe had just come back home from a gardening allotment with his tools, along with a basket of vegetables.
According to the piece, the specific tools at issue were a Niwaki Hori Hori gardening trowel and an Ice Bear Japanese gardener’s sickle.
Recalling the moment police showed up at his doorstep, Rowe told the paper, “I just heard shouting behind me, and then two armed officers shouting at me to drop the knife… And then they turned me around, pushed me up against my house, cuffed me, and then they arrested me, put me in the back of the van.”
Rowe was then taken to the police station and interrogated. The article stated that Rowe “was interviewed without legal representation as officers had been unable to reach a solicitor, and after spending several hours in custody he said he accepted a caution so he would be released.” A BBC article on the incident reported that Rowe said he was held for 12 hours.
In the U.K., a “caution” is something a person receives after admitting to an offense. According to the U.K. government, a caution is not a criminal conviction but remains on a person’s record and “could be used as evidence of bad character if you go to court for another crime.”
Rowe is now seeking to remove the caution from his record, concerned that the mark could imperil his career prospects. Moreover, the BBC reported that Rowe is “now scared to continue with what had been a lifelong hobby.”
As Vice President JD Vance and the U.S. State Department have pointed out, the U.K. does not have meaningful freedom of speech. Still, just what type of speech the police will waste their time on is truly shocking.
Following several shoplifting incidents, Rob Davies, owner of Run Ragged vintage shop in Wrexham, posted a sign explaining why he was forced to put some of his merchandise out of customer reach. Specifically, the sign told shoppers “Due to scumbags shoplifting, please ask for assistance to open cabinets. Thank you.”
Evidently, referring to criminals as “scumbags” is suspect on Airstrip One. According to an item from the Daily Mail, “police told [Davies] to change his sign calling shoplifters ‘scumbags’ because it may be offensive.” Davies refused to alter the language and has since printed further signs.
The shopkeeper has good reason to be frustrated. According to the article, “the hard-working retailer put [the sign] up after he caught five thieves red-handed in the last 12 months alone… He felt the police did little to help when he reported the five thefts and so he gave up doing so.” A BBC item on the incident noted, “Official figures released in July show shoplifting in Wales and England is at its highest level since current records began more than two decades ago.”
With the U.K. government finding new, petty, and bizarre ways to oppress its subjects, Americans should work to reaffirm our commitment to individual liberty, lest we end up going down the same dark path.