Explore The NRA Universe Of Websites

APPEARS IN News

Academic Freedom Survives Campus Carry Law Despite Self-Inflicted “Chilling” of Speech

Friday, August 30, 2019

Academic Freedom Survives Campus Carry Law Despite Self-Inflicted “Chilling” of Speech

Back in 2016, Dr. Jennifer Lynn Glass, Dr. Lisa Moore and Dr. Mia Carter, all professors at the University of Texas at Austin (UT), sued the university and the State of Texas over a 2015 law that allowed certain license holders to concealed-carry handguns on public college campuses.

The main argument advanced by the three academics was that the law (and the UT policies implementing the law) violated their free speech rights. “Compelling professors at a public university to allow, without any limitation or restriction, students to carry concealed guns in their classrooms chills their First Amendment rights to academic freedom.” The professors, as part of their teaching responsibilities, engage in classroom discussions of “controversial, emotionally-laden topics.” As alleged in their complaint, though, the possible presence of any of the less-than-one-percent of UT students licensed to carry would make it “inevitable” that the professors would “have to pull back, consciously or sub-consciously, at important junctures in classroom exposition and discussion” due to their fear that a more robust and unrestrained debate would incite “violent classroom action with a gun.” More broadly, the professors claimed that simply the possibility of a lawfully-carrying student being in the classroom “would jeopardize the community of trust and be destructive to the dynamic educational process” for educators and students alike.

The court of first instance refused to grant the preliminary injunction sought by the plaintiffs, on the basis that their First Amendment claim was meritless:

The court has searched the jurisprudence of this country from the ratification of the Constitution forward and has found no precedent for Plaintiffs’ proposition that there is a right of academic freedom so broad that it allows them such autonomous control of their classrooms – both physically and academically – that their concerns override decisions of the legislature and the governing body of the institution that employs them. 

The claim fared no better by the time the litigation reached the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. The appellate court confirmed that the plaintiffs lacked standing to bring their challenge because the harm they attributed to the state law and UT policies was, in essence, an unrelated, “self-imposed censoring of classroom discussion caused by their fear of the possibility of illegal activity” by students or others, where “none of the cited evidence alleges a certainty that a license-holder will illegally brandish a firearm in a classroom.” Accordingly, the plaintiffs failed to establish the necessary violation of their rights or interests, one that was directly connected to the government action at issue.  

The plaintiffs continue to be listed as UT’s faculty and staff. However, a source that contacted the plaintiffs for their reactions, now that three years have passed since the lawsuit, reports that Dr. Carter “did not respond to multiple requests for comment;” Dr. Moore stated, “I’m not able to help, I’m sorry,” without further explanation; and Dr. Glass declined to comment or respond to “followup questions regarding the campus climate and whether or not guns had had any effect on it over the past few years, inside or outside the classroom.”

As academics, all three plaintiffs presumably share fundamental professional values on the empirical differences between opinion and fact, belief and evidence. Indeed, Professor Carter specifically professed, as part of the lawsuit, that her “pedagogic approach emphasizes dialogue and debate and the critical examination of one’s own ideas and others’ beliefs.” It is puzzling that they have refused to comment on the actual fallout of the 2015 law, or acknowledge that allowing law-abiding students to carry on campus has not – contrary to dire predictions – extinguished the free exchange of ideas or otherwise oppressed the university’s educational mission.

In the end, what is more obvious than ever is that the only “chilling effect” of the law on academic speech is nothing more than a self-inflicted silence resting on irrational prejudices about lawful concealed carriers.

 

TRENDING NOW
Nevada: Battle-Tested State Becomes Battleground for Second Amendment Rights

Friday, November 13, 2026

Nevada: Battle-Tested State Becomes Battleground for Second Amendment Rights

The election is over, but national gun control groups are already setting their sights on Nevadan's Second Amendment rights.   

Judge Rules DOJ Lacks Authority to Pursue Second Amendment Violations

News  

Monday, November 16, 2026

Judge Rules DOJ Lacks Authority to Pursue Second Amendment Violations

Harmeet Dhillon, the now-former Assistant Attorney General of the U.S. Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division (CRIT), has been appropriately hailed as “a jewel for justice” and “the face of the [Trump] administration’s commitment to ...

Democrats Promised Affordability Agenda, Immediately Pivot to Pursuing Gun Control

News  

Monday, November 16, 2026

Democrats Promised Affordability Agenda, Immediately Pivot to Pursuing Gun Control

The election is over. The time for lamenting the results has passed. This is especially the case in states where anti-gun Democrats have secured complete control of government as their gun control proposals are already ...

Texas: A Flurry of Anti-Gun Bills Introduced on the First Day of Prefiling

Monday, November 9, 2026

Texas: A Flurry of Anti-Gun Bills Introduced on the First Day of Prefiling

Prefiling of legislative bills for the 2027 Regular Session of the Texas State Legislature began today. On the first day alone, legislators filed roughly 35 firearm-related bills, with the vast majority aimed are infringing on ...

ATF Director Robert Cekada Unbowed After Midterms: “We’re Forging Ahead”

News  

Monday, November 16, 2026

ATF Director Robert Cekada Unbowed After Midterms: “We’re Forging Ahead”

Recently, we reported on the departure of two key figures in the Trump administration’s pro-Second Amendment agenda.

Amtrak to Amend Firearms Policy to Align with President Trump’s 2A Executive Order

News  

Monday, November 16, 2026

Amtrak to Amend Firearms Policy to Align with President Trump’s 2A Executive Order

Gun owners may soon have an easier time traveling by Amtrak, with President Donald Trump to thank. Reports indicate that the heavily federally subsidized train service will change its policy starting in January 2027 to ...

Michigan: California-Style Training Requirements Being Proposed in Michigan

Friday, November 13, 2026

Michigan: California-Style Training Requirements Being Proposed in Michigan

House Bill 6477, introduced this week by Rep. Sharon MacDonell (D-Troy) and referred to the House Committee on Government Operations, amends Michigan’s License to Purchase (LTP) law (MCL 28.422). It adds a new training requirement before ...

Ohio: Suppressor Bill on the Move, Take Action Today!

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Ohio: Suppressor Bill on the Move, Take Action Today!

Today, the House Public Safety Committee passed SB 214, legislation to remove firearm suppressors from the definition of “dangerous ordnance” in the Ohio Revised Code, and it is now eligible for floor votes in the ...

Ohio: Suppressor Bill Sails Through Floor Votes and Heads to Governor's Desk!

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Ohio: Suppressor Bill Sails Through Floor Votes and Heads to Governor's Desk!

Today, SB 214, legislation to remove firearm suppressors, short barreled rifles, and short barreled shotguns, from the definition of “dangerous ordnance” in the Ohio Revised Code, quickly advanced through the Ohio legislature and now heads ...

U.S. House Passes Repeal of Social Security Administration Gun Grab, Begins Rolling Back Obama Era Executive Gun Control

News  

Friday, February 3, 2017

U.S. House Passes Repeal of Social Security Administration Gun Grab, Begins Rolling Back Obama Era Executive Gun Control

On Thursday, the U.S. House of Representatives issued a strong statement in support of the Second Amendment by passing H.J. Res. 40, which would repeal Barack Obama’s scandalous attempt to grab guns from thousands of vulnerable, ...

MORE TRENDING +
LESS TRENDING -

More Like This From Around The NRA

NRA ILA

Established in 1975, the Institute for Legislative Action (ILA) is the "lobbying" arm of the National Rifle Association of America. ILA is responsible for preserving the right of all law-abiding individuals in the legislative, political, and legal arenas, to purchase, possess and use firearms for legitimate purposes as guaranteed by the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.