Explore The NRA Universe Of Websites

APPEARS IN News

Six Year Wait for Recovery of Seized Guns Ruled Unconstitutional

Friday, June 10, 2016

Six Year Wait for Recovery of Seized Guns Ruled Unconstitutional

Law enforcement officers seize privately-owned firearms in a variety of situations.  The problem, as we’ve written about previously, is that once a gun has been seized, the police often refuse to restore it to its lawful owner, even when the owner hasn’t done anything wrong: he or she hasn’t been convicted of or even accused of committing any crime, isn’t disqualified from possessing or owning firearms, and the gun isn’t needed for a police investigation or as evidence. When the value of the firearm is less than cost of the anticipated legal fees to contest the seizure and compel the return of the gun, many owners have little real choice but to forfeit their lawful property.

An obvious problem.

A federal court in Rhode Island has recently ruled that a municipality and its police chief violated a gun owner’s constitutionally protected due process rights by refusing to return his lawfully owned firearms for over six years, without providing a mechanism by which such seizures could be reviewed and resolved.

In 2008, during a troubled point in their marriage, Jason Richer’s wife called the police, saying he was suicidal and had ingested some pills. The police responded and Mr. Richer was taken for a mental health evaluation. He was released the same day. While at the home, though, the officers confiscated two rifles and a shotgun kept in a locked case in his garage, citing “safekeeping” and public safety concerns. The police checked to confirm the guns were not implicated in illegal activity, and Mr. Richer was not charged with any crime resulting from this incident. Three weeks later, when he went to retrieve his guns, the officers refused to give them back, claiming Mr. Richer would need a court order authorizing the release. Mr. Richer later repeated his demand in writing, even including a letter from his psychologist that confirmed his mental well-being. Richer made several additional demands for his guns before resorting to litigation. His lawsuit claimed that the Town of North Smithfield and its police chief violated his state and federal constitutional rights, including his due process and Second Amendment rights.  

The Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution prohibits a deprivation of life, liberty or property “without due process of law.” This requires, generally, a determination of the kind of procedural protection that applies to a person who, like Mr. Richer, is found to have suffered a constitutional deprivation. The defendants argued that there was no due process violation because Mr. Richer had access to adequate procedures: he could obtain new guns, or sue in state court for the return of the seized guns at any time.

The federal court rejected these arguments as unfounded. Placing the financial, procedural and temporal burden of the entire recovery process on the claimant alone did not meet due process requirements in this case. Although the town did have a strong interest in public safety at the time of the initial seizure, once a person whose guns were taken is able to legally acquire new guns, the retention of that person’s seized guns does nothing to protect the public from potential harm. Similarly, the town could not justify its actions based on an abstract fear of potential liability if guns were returned to a person who later misused them, because this rationale “only comes at the expense of individual procedural rights.”

While the federal court concluded that access to a state court action was insufficient, it declined to determine the kind of procedural protection that would be required. Because Mr. Richer had been reunited with his guns while the lawsuit was pending (and some six and a half years after the seizure), the court “need not prescribe specific procedures in order to resolve his claim.” The decision is Richer v. Parmalee, No. 15-162-M-PAS, 2016 WL 3094487 (D. R.I., June 1, 2016).

TRENDING NOW
Nevada: Battle-Tested State Becomes Battleground for Second Amendment Rights

Friday, November 13, 2026

Nevada: Battle-Tested State Becomes Battleground for Second Amendment Rights

The election is over, but national gun control groups are already setting their sights on Nevadan's Second Amendment rights.   

Judge Rules DOJ Lacks Authority to Pursue Second Amendment Violations

News  

Monday, November 16, 2026

Judge Rules DOJ Lacks Authority to Pursue Second Amendment Violations

Harmeet Dhillon, the now-former Assistant Attorney General of the U.S. Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division (CRIT), has been appropriately hailed as “a jewel for justice” and “the face of the [Trump] administration’s commitment to ...

Democrats Promised Affordability Agenda, Immediately Pivot to Pursuing Gun Control

News  

Monday, November 16, 2026

Democrats Promised Affordability Agenda, Immediately Pivot to Pursuing Gun Control

The election is over. The time for lamenting the results has passed. This is especially the case in states where anti-gun Democrats have secured complete control of government as their gun control proposals are already ...

Texas: A Flurry of Anti-Gun Bills Introduced on the First Day of Prefiling

Monday, November 9, 2026

Texas: A Flurry of Anti-Gun Bills Introduced on the First Day of Prefiling

Prefiling of legislative bills for the 2027 Regular Session of the Texas State Legislature began today. On the first day alone, legislators filed roughly 35 firearm-related bills, with the vast majority aimed are infringing on ...

ATF Director Robert Cekada Unbowed After Midterms: “We’re Forging Ahead”

News  

Monday, November 16, 2026

ATF Director Robert Cekada Unbowed After Midterms: “We’re Forging Ahead”

Recently, we reported on the departure of two key figures in the Trump administration’s pro-Second Amendment agenda.

Amtrak to Amend Firearms Policy to Align with President Trump’s 2A Executive Order

News  

Monday, November 16, 2026

Amtrak to Amend Firearms Policy to Align with President Trump’s 2A Executive Order

Gun owners may soon have an easier time traveling by Amtrak, with President Donald Trump to thank. Reports indicate that the heavily federally subsidized train service will change its policy starting in January 2027 to ...

Michigan: California-Style Training Requirements Being Proposed in Michigan

Friday, November 13, 2026

Michigan: California-Style Training Requirements Being Proposed in Michigan

House Bill 6477, introduced this week by Rep. Sharon MacDonell (D-Troy) and referred to the House Committee on Government Operations, amends Michigan’s License to Purchase (LTP) law (MCL 28.422). It adds a new training requirement before ...

Ohio: Suppressor Bill on the Move, Take Action Today!

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Ohio: Suppressor Bill on the Move, Take Action Today!

Today, the House Public Safety Committee passed SB 214, legislation to remove firearm suppressors from the definition of “dangerous ordnance” in the Ohio Revised Code, and it is now eligible for floor votes in the ...

Ohio: Suppressor Bill Sails Through Floor Votes and Heads to Governor's Desk!

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Ohio: Suppressor Bill Sails Through Floor Votes and Heads to Governor's Desk!

Today, SB 214, legislation to remove firearm suppressors, short barreled rifles, and short barreled shotguns, from the definition of “dangerous ordnance” in the Ohio Revised Code, quickly advanced through the Ohio legislature and now heads ...

U.S. House Passes Repeal of Social Security Administration Gun Grab, Begins Rolling Back Obama Era Executive Gun Control

News  

Friday, February 3, 2017

U.S. House Passes Repeal of Social Security Administration Gun Grab, Begins Rolling Back Obama Era Executive Gun Control

On Thursday, the U.S. House of Representatives issued a strong statement in support of the Second Amendment by passing H.J. Res. 40, which would repeal Barack Obama’s scandalous attempt to grab guns from thousands of vulnerable, ...

MORE TRENDING +
LESS TRENDING -

More Like This From Around The NRA

NRA ILA

Established in 1975, the Institute for Legislative Action (ILA) is the "lobbying" arm of the National Rifle Association of America. ILA is responsible for preserving the right of all law-abiding individuals in the legislative, political, and legal arenas, to purchase, possess and use firearms for legitimate purposes as guaranteed by the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.